Wednesday, June 7, 2023
HomeTechnologyI tested Google Bard's new coding skills. It didn't go well

I tested Google Bard’s new coding skills. It didn’t go well

Photograph Illustration by Rafael Henrique/SOPA Photographs/LightRocket by way of Getty Photographs

Beforehand, we mentioned how Bard can present some coding assist to programmers, however could not code. That is modified. As of Friday, Google has introduced Bard can code. However can it code effectively?

Let’s discover out.

Additionally: One of the best AI artwork mills to attempt

To give you a solution, I will run among the coding assessments I gave to ChatGPT. We’ll see how Bard does, and examine the outcomes.

Writing a easy WordPress plugin

My preliminary foray into ChatGPT coding was with a WordPress PHP plugin that supplied some performance my spouse wanted on her web site. It was a easy request, merely asking for some submitted strains to be sorted and de-duped, however when ChatGPT wrote it, it gave my spouse a software that helped her save time on a repetitive process she does recurrently for work.

This is the immediate:

Write a PHP 8 suitable WordPress plugin that gives a textual content entry discipline the place an inventory of strains might be pasted into it and a button, that when pressed, randomizes the strains within the record and presents the leads to a second textual content entry discipline with no clean strains and makes certain no two an identical entries are subsequent to one another (until there isn’t any different possibility)…with the variety of strains submitted and the variety of strains within the consequence an identical to one another. Underneath the primary discipline, show textual content stating “Line to randomize: ” with the variety of nonempty strains within the supply discipline. Underneath the second discipline, show textual content stating “Traces which have been randomized: ” with the variety of non-empty strains within the vacation spot discipline.

And here is the generated code that Bard wrote:


Screenshot by David Gewirtz/ZDNET

Thus far, it appears good. However not a lot. The UI isn’t formatted correctly. Worse, the plugin does not work. Clicking the Randomize button simply leads to each fields being cleared. That is it.


Screenshot by David Gewirtz/ZDNET

In contrast, ChatGPT constructed a totally purposeful plugin proper out of the gate.

Fixing some code

Subsequent, I attempted a routine I would beforehand fed into ChatGPT that got here from my precise programming workflow. I used to be debugging some JavaScript code and located that I had an enter validator that did not deal with decimal values. It could settle for integers, but when somebody tried to feed in {dollars} and cents, it failed.

Additionally: What’s generative AI and why is it so standard? This is every thing to know

I fed Bard the identical immediate I fed ChatGPT, and that is what resulted:


Screenshot by David Gewirtz/ZDNET

The code generated right here was for much longer than what got here again from ChatGPT. That is as a result of Bard did not do any common expression calculations in its response and gave again a quite simple script that you simply’d anticipate from a primary 12 months programming scholar.

Additionally: Methods to use ChatGPT to write down Excel formulation

Additionally, like one thing you’d anticipate from a primary 12 months programming scholar, it was flawed. It correctly validates the worth to the left of the decimal, however permits any worth (together with letters and symbols) to the proper of the decimal.

Discovering a bug

Throughout that very same programming day, I encountered a PHP bug that was actually irritating me. While you name a perform, you typically go parameters. You want to write the perform to have the ability to settle for the variety of parameters the originating name sends to it.

Additionally: Methods to use Midjourney to generate superb pictures

So far as I may inform, my perform was sending the proper variety of parameters, but I stored getting an incorrect parameter depend error. This is the immediate:


Screenshot by David Gewirtz/ZDNET

After I fed the issue into ChatGPT, the AI appropriately recognized that I wanted to vary code within the hook (the interface between my perform and the primary utility) to account for parameters. It was completely right and saved me from tearing out my hair.

I handed Bard the identical downside, and here is its reply:


Screenshot by David Gewirtz/ZDNET

Unsuitable, once more. This time, Bard merely instructed me that the issue I used to be having was a mismatch of parameters, and I wanted to go the donation ID. That was a flawed reply. As soon as once more, ChatGPT succeeded and Bard failed.

For the file, I checked out all three of Bard’s drafts for this reply, they usually had been all flawed.

‘Good day, world’ check

Final week, I requested ChatGPT to generate code in 12 standard programming languages (together with Python) to show “Good day, world” ten instances, and to find out if it was morning, afternoon, or night right here in Oregon. ChatGPT succeeded for the mainstream languages.

Additionally: This new know-how may blow away GPT-4 and every thing prefer it

I fed the identical immediate to Bard. Because it has been flawed on every thing to date, I simply picked one language to check, asking it to generate some Python code:


Screenshot by David Gewirtz/ZDNET

Though Bard’s technique for figuring out time was a bit extra convoluted than it wanted to be, the consequence was workable.

So, can Bard code?

Bard can undoubtedly write code. However in three of my 4 assessments, the code it wrote did not work correctly. So I would not essentially say that Bard can code.

I am going to let you know this. If I had been hiring a programmer and gave them the above 4 assignments as a manner of testing their programming expertise, they usually returned the identical outcomes as Bard, I would not rent them.

Additionally: Generative AI is altering your tech profession path. What to know

Proper now, Bard can write code… like a primary 12 months programming scholar who will most likely get a C grade for the semester.

Given how good ChatGPT is, Google’s reply is … embarrassing.

You possibly can observe my day-to-day challenge updates on social media. Make sure to observe me on Twitter at @DavidGewirtz, on Fb at, on Instagram at, and on YouTube at




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments